Читать книгу Controversy Mapping - Tommaso Venturini - Страница 4

1 Preface: The politics of association on display by Richard RogersFigure 0 Mapping the online mentions of rare minerals

2 IntroductionFigure 1 Tree of disagreements around the conservation of Amboseli elephantsFigure 2 Actor/issue table of the Amboseli controversyFigure 3 Network of actors in the Amboseli controversyFigure 4 Debate scales and scale inversion in the Amboseli controversyFigure 5 Stream diagram of the temporal evolution of the Amboseli controversy

3 Chapter 1Figure 6 Map of how three different indexes of vulnerability disagree in assessing countr…Figure 7 Bilateral adaptation funding and vulnerability indexingFigure 8 Controversy mappers accused of spying on wind turbine opponentsFigure 9 Four criteria for estimating the feasibility of a controversy mapping projectFigure 10 The hype cycle of controversy mapping

4 Chapter 2Figure 11 First attempt at inventorying the issues surrounding the plans for developing th…Figure 12 1934 map of Southern Copenhagen circulated by the developer as part of the debat…Figure 13 Map of the area where the development is planned showing the concentration of un…Figure 14 Map demonstrating that the construction site is on the site of the old landfillFigure 15 Two of the photos showing how in 2001 the meadows were almost completely strippe…Figure 16 Map of the area showing the location of the red-listed species and the planned d…

5 Chapter 3Figure 17 Screenshot of a post on the Friends of the Common Facebook group with the three …Figure 18 Artistic rendition of the proposed artificial island “Nordhaleøen”Figure 19 Area chart showing the shifting prevalence of different issues in the Friends of…Figure 20 “Angry” and “love” reactions to posts and comments in the Friends of the Common…Figure 21 Facebook posts from the Friends of the Common group, and from the pages for the …Figure 22 Banksy, Love Is in The Air, Flower Thrower, 2005

6 Chapter 4Figure 23 Elements of a terroir, as told by Jean-Marie around his vineyards in BerlouFigure 24 Extract from the official map of the Languedoc AOCsFigure 25 Trained vines with irrigation system on the plains near Béziers and troll vines on…Figure 26 Cellar floor, fermentation tanks, and the dog named Terroir in Béziers; cellar f…Figure 27 A semiotic triangle of French wine oppositionsFigure 28 Three ways of telling the story of French wine and terroir using Greimas’s model …Figure 29 A diagram of programs and anti-programs of action in a hotel receptionFigure 30 Markings on a street encouraging social distancing in front of a rotisserie kios…Figure 31 The trajectory of the TSR2 projectFigure 32 The redirection of actions through the obligatory passage point (OPP) proposed b…Figure 33 The Centre Pompidou in ParisFigure 34a Network of actors cast for HBO series visualized by separating actors and seriesFigure 34b Network of actors cast for HBO series visualized by keeping actors and series on…Figure 35a Luc Boltanski’s original table of the French dominant classFigure 35b A redesign of figure 35a as a network with institutions and individuals connecte…Figure 36 Hope by Shepard Fairey (2008) courtesy of Obey Giant, flanked by the original ph…

7 Chapter 5Figure 37 South Korean search interest in the topics “Coronavirus,” “Mask,” and “Vaccines”…Figure 38 German search interest in the topics “Coronavirus,” “Mask,” and “Vaccines” overl…Figure 39 German search interest in the topics “Zoom Video Communications,” “Toilet Paper,…Figure 40 Search topics related to the topic “Coronavirus” in Germany between February 19 …Figure 41 The divide between qualitative and quantitative methods as revealed by a visual …Figure 42 The three generations of social sciencesFigure 43 The power-law distribution of online attention and the popularity and personaliz…

8 Chapter 6Figure 44 The research chain of digital methods and how it will be covered in the followin…Figure 45 Thirteen pages discovered by crawling the “Circumcision controversies” page on W…Figure 46 Network obtained by crawling the “Circumcision controversies” page on Wikipedia …Figure 47 Network obtained by crawling the “Circumcision controversies” page on Wikipedia …Figure 48 Network of pages from the “Circumcision” category on Wikipedia connected by all …Figure 49 An example of a link template from WikipediaFigure 50 Network of pages from the “Circumcision” category on Wikipedia connected to each…Figure 51 Network of pages from the “Circumcision” category on Wikipedia connected by the …Figure 52 Three versions of the same network of pages from the “Circumcision” category on …Figure 53a Apparent correlation between queries for “side effects” and the unemployment rat…Figure 53b The similarity of trends in Google Trends for the queries “symptoms,” “side effe…Figure 54 An example of a sophisticated search query in ISI Web of ScienceFigure 55 The Palestinian Blogosphere as crawled by Anat Ben-David in 2007Figure 56 The three-layered model of online connectivity and the three-step crawling prot…Figure 57 Network shortcuts and the formation of small worlds in clustered networksFigure 58 Normal distribution of connectivity in the US highway system; and the power-law …

9 Chapter 7Figure 59 HPV vaccination activity in Denmark month by month from 2009 to 2016, Danish med…Figure 60 Mentions of “side effect” in Danish Facebook conversations related to the HPV va…Figure 61 Network of Facebook posts mentioning both “HPV” and “side effects” from 2012 to …Figure 62 Two renderings of a network of Wikipedia pages related to the Green RevolutionFigure 63 Central and bridging nodes in the Green Revolution networkFigure 64 Authorities and hubs in the Green Revolution networkFigure 65 The Green Revolution network according to our manual thematic classification of …Figure 66 Turning the city of Königsberg and its bridges into a matrix of associationsFigure 67 Headline, subhead and lead of Moreno’s 1933 New York Times interview; Jacob More…Figure 68a The London Underground map before Harry Beck’s redesignFigure 68b The London Underground map after Harry Beck’s redesign

10 Chapter 8Figure 69 Network of scientific literature related to “AI for humanity” visualized as a contour mapFigure 70 Setup for the presentation of our scientometric maps at the “Global Forum for Ar…Figure 71 The same network of scientific literature related to “AI for humanity” as seen f…Figure 72 The same network of scientific literature related to “AI for humanity” as seen f…Figure 73 Negotiations in the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (1995–…Figure 74 Rise and fall in the visibility of issues in the international climate negotiati…Figure 75 The level of intervention of the 21 most active countries in the UNFCCC negotiat…Figure 76 Two unsatisfactory maps: too complex and too simplifiedFigure 77 The controversy atlas as a way to manage the trade-off between the richness that…Figure 78 An example of a tree of disagreements (reproduced from figure 1)Figure 79 An example of an actor/issue table (reproduced from figure 2)Figure 80 An example of a network diagram (reproduced from figure 3)Figure 81 An example of debate scales (reproduced from figure 4)Figure 82 An example of debate dynamics (reproduced from figure 5)Figure 83 Ten types of evolution in the complexity of a controversy over timeFigure 84 The narration-exploration circle of controversy mappingFigure 85 Datascape navigation on lafabriquedelaloi.frFigure 86a Recipe for tracing the fate of a fake news story online: the digital methods pro…Figure 86b Recipe for tracing the fate of a fake news story online: the resulting visualiza…

11 Chapter 9Figure 87 The spiral of public participation

12 Controversy mapping in the shadow of GaiaFigure 88 The planet Melancholia crashing into the Earth in the 2011 movie by Lars von Tri…Figure 89 Lynn Margulis carving a sample from the cyanobacteria tissue responsible for the…Figure 90 Two of the first and most famous pictures of the Earth seen from space, Earthris…