Читать книгу Hydraulic Fluid Power - Andrea Vacca - Страница 27
2.2.6 Comparisons Between Hydraulic Fluids
ОглавлениеA good summary of the main properties of different hydraulic fluids is provided in Table 2.2. This summarizes the data that can be found in literature [11], although one must consider that the use of additives can significantly alter the properties indicated in the table. Notwithstanding, the table is particularly significant in its last column, which quantifies the relative costs of different fluids. Assuming the reference cost of a mineral oil being 100 (the actual value fluctuates depending on several economic factors), the cost of all other oils is at least double. This is the main reason for the popularity of mineral‐based oils.
Table 2.2 Comparison between different hydraulic fluids.
Source: Adapted from Assofluid [11].
Fluid | Density (kg/m3) | Viscosity Index (VI) | Lubricating power | Fire resistance | Antioxidizing power | Maximum temperature (°C) | Toxicity | Average cost |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mineral oil | 870–900 | 70–100 | Excellent | Poor | Excellent | −5 to 70 | Low | 100 |
Vegetable oila | 920 | 210 | Excellent | Good | Fairly good | −10 to 70 | No toxicity | 250 |
Polyglycolsa | 1100 | 150–200 | Excellent | Good | Good | −30 to 80 | No toxicity | 350 |
Synthetic estersa | 920 | 200 | Excellent | Good | Good | −30 to 100 | No toxicity | 700 |
Water‐in‐oil | 915–940 | High | Fairly good | Excellent | Good | 0–50 | Low | 200 |
Water glycol | 1060 | High | Fairly good | Excellent | Good | 0–50 | Low | 400 |
Chlorinated hydrocarbons | 1430 | Low | Good | Good | Fairly good | −5 to 70 | High | 700 |
Phosphoric esters | 1270 | Low | Excellent | Good | Fairly good | −5 to 70 | High | 500 |
Mixture of esters and chlorides | 1150 | Low | Excellent | Good | Fairly good | −5 to 70 | High | 600 |
Silicones | 930–1030 | High | Fairly good | Excellent | Fairly good | −5 to 90 | Low | <700 |
a Refers to biodegradable fluids.