Читать книгу The Power of Being - Андреас Грубер - Страница 7
5 Where do opinions come from?
ОглавлениеTraveling is a great opportunity to learn something about ourselves, partly because we are out of our comfort zone a great deal of the time. What also becomes quite evident is that people in other countries think differently. That is due to the cultural background. Our opinions get influenced by our culture as well as our religion, social background, family, education, etc. All that merges into a belief system. A part of that belief system is our values, which tend to be rather stable over time while our opinions can change quickly and often.
We may, for example, be rather tolerant towards foreigners. Our view is that they contribute to diversity in our country. A few months later a war causes a massive wave of refugees to swamp our nation, at least if we believe the media. We seem to be drowning in foreigners, and so is our opinion. Subsequently, we now form another one, based on the situation we have not yet experienced ourselves, but that is described as a fact in the newspapers. It may all be true, and it may as well not be, but the fact is that our opinions tend to blow like flags in the wind.
"History will be kind to me, for I intend to write it."
As I was doing business with a company in Los Angeles in the nineties, large fires were reported to be threatening southern California. I phoned with the owner of that company and asked him if they were in danger. He laughed out loud and said, "No, but we probably have most of the cameras in the world here, and the media people don't have much to do now, so they make this look huge." So sometimes our opinions are shaped by media people who don't have anything else to do or are just looking for the ultimate scoop.
A journalist could make a little bushfirelook like Southern California is threatened.Luckily this never happens!And of course, we would never believe it anyway...
I recently had a long and interesting conversation with a holy man in India. He was extremely well educated by western standards, spoke English fluently and read three newspapers every day. We came to talk about the tragic event in Delhi, of a young woman being brutally gang raped on a bus, leading to her death shortly after. I stated that many women in the west did not dare to go to India on vacation because of this, even though it is such a beautiful country. This kind man could sincerely not understand why, because according to his knowledge every second woman in the West has been raped anyway. I was stunned. But this was not ignorance from his side; this had been reported by serious Indian newspapers. The problem was that he would rather believe an Indian newspaper over a westerner who lives in the place he's talking about. It seems we are lost if we let media set the level of our knowledge.
Mass media either stops a war, starts a war, or keeps it going.They can be as much part of it, like rifles and bullets.That's where we get our news, facts, and truths.
Opinions tend to be based on assumptions that are based on information. If the information we have, is also unreliable and on top of that we are unaware of our very own assumptions, how can we then trust our opinions? It may never have occurred to you that you could be unaware of your assumptions, right?
I assure you that I had many exciting meetings when I gently started asking what assumptions a person’s opinion or idea was based on. Often people hadn't really thought about it. We call this, jumping to conclusions. I made that mistake myself many times, and I still do. Probably because I’m assuming that I know, or thinking I'm so smart. How many fights and wars can we put on this account, just within the last century? People jumping to conclusions, based on uncertain facts and unquestioned assumptions, leading to the wrong actions.
The foundation of a good decision is to question our sources, assumptions and the process, being aware that we are biased.
Furthermore, a person who is trapped in a belief system does not really have a free mind or a free will.
Many of the classic Greek philosophers were concerned with, how to reason properly to make the best use of the mind within the framework of logical reasoning. One could study that subject for quite a while, and still not know, what to do practically on a daily basis. I had the privilege to spend one month with one of the clearest thinkers alive in Europe. His IQ is supposed to be higher than Einstein's IQ was. We spent, at least, two hours per day, only the two of us, explicitly reasoning about seemingly unsolvable questions. I would deliver the questions, and he would mainly deliver the reasoning while he was thinking out loud.
To reason is ancient nonsense.To reflect is a sign of sadness.Awareness is a word in the dictionary.To daydream is the new thinking.What's next?
Over the years, I collected and tried many different approaches to reasoning. I won't bore you with all the details, but here are a few that may interest you:
To question the assumptions behind your opinions. List them and dissect them one by one.
To ask yourself what you do NOT know about a certain matter.
To test your attachment to an idea, by assuming the opposite and observing your natural impulse or reactions.
To pay attention to the hunch you had about something, in the very first moment, you heard or saw it, and follow that path consequently.
To invite a nay-sayer, to give his contributions.
To question what our values have to do with our personal wounds and consciously integrate that and be aware how that affects our view.
To eliminate our professional view, to come out of our "deformation professionelle", see comment after the next chart.
To let the mind rest, while holding a complex question, without reasoning or thinking about it.
To assume you have another belief system, and approach the matter from there.
To "slip into the moccasins" of another person and to view the issue from that standpoint.
Some of these approaches would appeal our right brain or non-conceptual thinking while others engage both sides. They will partly be dealt with throughout this book.
Although this book is not specifically about the left and right brain, it is clear that there is a connection to being vs. doing, as the list above demonstrates.
"Deformation professionelle," is a French definition, which practically means that if we for example are teachers, lawyers or doctors we are likely to see everything as teachers, lawyers or doctors even when we are doing something that is out of our usual context. Over the years, our professional view tends to become one with our personality. We even tend to say, I am a teacher, or I am a lawyer or a doctor because this often becomes more than just a job for us. It represents the spectacles we see the world through. And wisely, the French have identified this as a potential deformation of our perception. And by the way, this is the reason it is extremely beneficial for corporations to have a certain percentage of outsiders coming from alien fields of work because they are likely to stay clear of that deformation for quite a while.
Over time, our profession deforms our minds and views, to a degree, where even common sense gets lost.Outsiders are the cure if we would only listen to them.
We ought to explore and make the best use of our minds. To find friends and colleagues to argue with for the sake of sharpening our mind can be very useful and even entertaining and helps us to break through some of the traps of our minds. We must never allow our minds to become dull if we are interested in being good decision makers and leaders.
Last but not least, we are not only externally influenced and torn and blown in all directions, but we are also governed by a multitude of internal factors, that we usually don't give much attention.